Chancellor reform

Proposals for legislation and discussions of these

Moderator: SC Moderators

Post Reply
Dnate Mars
Veteran debater
Veteran debater
Posts: 285
Joined: Fri May 26, 2006 9:32 am

Chancellor reform

Post by Dnate Mars »

Since it has been brought up, again, I figured it is time to bring up a bill from last year. We will start with the bill that was rejected and see where we can go from there:

Dnate Mars wrote:

Article II - The Executive

Section 1 - The Chancellor

The Chancellor will serve as the executive of CDS, working to coordinate and plan community projects, and to act as a head of the State for the CDS project.

Section 2 - Powers of the Chancellor

The Chancellor of CDS shall, subject to the laws of CDS, have the power:

(a) to determine the use to which any and all land in CDS shall be put;

(b) to expend monies held by the Office of the Chancellor of CDS for the administration and management of public facilities (including, but not limited to, roadways, signage, public buildings, public events and similar), and to discharge any other duties or powers of the Office of the Chancellor conferred by this Act or any other Act of the Representative Assembly;

(c) to publicize CDS;

(d) to appoint and pay deputies or other staff to hold office in the Office of the Chancellor of CDS to facilitate the discharge of any function of the Office of the Chancellor conferred by this Act or any other Act of the Representative Assembly.

(i)Staff that is mandated by the RA that the Chancellor must appoint will require a majority approvial by the RA before that person will be placed into the position. To remove this appointed person from office, the RA must appove of the removal also.

(ii)Staff that is not mandated by the RA will serve at the will of the Chancellor. This means that these people can be removed form their positions with or without reason by the Chancellor.

(e) subject to the payment of adequate compensation to any citizen or citizens thereby affected, reclaim or swap any land held by any citizen of CDS for the purposes of discharging any function of the Office of the Chancellor conferred by this Act or any other Act of the Representative Assembly, provided always that no citizen of CDS shall not be caused to have no holding in CDS at all thereby;

(f) to make regulations pursuant to the above;

(g) to enforce such regulations in accordance with law;

(h) to act as the head of the state in dealing with outside entities such as foreign nations or Linden Lab.

Section 3 - Public Oversight

The Chancellor must provide for regular and active citizen participation and public review of any decision concerning land use or the aesthetic or functional environment.

The Chancellor will deliver a public report on the State of the CDS in March and October of each year.

Section 4 - Themes

Nothing in this Act shall give the Chancellor of CDS any power to change the overall theme of Neufriestadt or any other sim or administered component of the CDS.

Section 5 - Chancellor Selection Process

The Chancellor of the CDS shall be selected by the people of the CDS from among any CDS citizen who shall make application to the SC. Each voter will rank the Chancellors running as to order of perferance. To be elected as Chancellor, at least 50% of the votes must be in favor of the Chancellor. If the first count does not elect an chancellor, the candidate with the fewest votes will be eliminated until the single candidate receives 50% of the votes.

The application period shall end fifteen (15) days before the next general election. This provision shall come into force with the next RA election following passage and ratification of this amendment.

The chancellor will serve a term ending with the election of the next chancellor.

The Chancellor may not be elected to or serve on the Representative Assembly, nor serve on the Scientific Council.

Section 6 - The Chancellor's Veto

The Chancellor shall have the power to veto any act of the Representative Assembly, except any bill to remove the Chancellor from office. The Representative Assembly may override a veto with a vote by at least a two-thirds majority. In order to exercise the power of veto, the Chancellor shall post a public declaration of her or his intention to exercise that power, together with the name of the Act in respect of which he or she seeks so to exercise, and the reasons for exercising it in respect of that Act, on the Confederation of Democratic Simulators web forums or wiki within seven days of the posting to the wiki of the Act in respect of which he or she seeks to exercise that power.

Section 7 - Removal from Office

The Chancellor may be removed from office prior to the expiration of the term of office by a bill passed with a two-thirds majority by the RA calling for the removal of the Chancellor. A vote by the citizens of the CDS will be held within 7 days of passing the bill lasting 7 days. If a majority of the votes are for the removal of the Chancellor, the Chancellor will be removed from office immediately.

Section 8 - RA Oversight

Each month the Chancellor shall attend a meeting of the Representative Assembly, and fully and truthfully answer there any questions posed by any citizen about any aspect of the affairs of the CDS or of the Office of the Chancellor. The Chancellor will also attend upon seven days notice at the written request from any member of the Representative Assembly.

Section 9 - AC Overlap

Any power or responsibility assigned to the Artisan's Collective by the constitution and precedent that overlaps those provided to the Chancellor in this amendment will be assigned to the Chancellor.

Jon Seattle
I need a hobby
I need a hobby
Posts: 648
Joined: Mon May 29, 2006 6:18 am

Re: Chancellor reform

Post by Jon Seattle »

Ah the "US President" bill. This was problematic the first time it was introduced. Can I take is that this bill, as written, already has the support of the SP, NuCARE, and DPU? If so, no point on my commenting.

User avatar
Arria Perreault
I need a hobby
I need a hobby
Posts: 630
Joined: Thu Feb 01, 2007 5:14 pm

Re: Chancellor reform

Post by Arria Perreault »

Dnate,

I really think that reinforce only Chancellor is not a good solution. The result seems clear to me: battle between RA and Chancellor with SC as arbiter. The best way to balance RA is the referendum right.
About Chancellor: I would like to read another word like government. I think that this office is not the office of one person, but of a team. The Chancellor would become a Prime Minister who works with other Ministers (another lost project...).

Cindy Ecksol
Master Word Wielder
Master Word Wielder
Posts: 449
Joined: Thu Jan 10, 2008 8:37 pm

Re: Chancellor reform

Post by Cindy Ecksol »

Dnate Mars wrote:

Since it has been brought up, again, I figured it is time to bring up a bill from last year. We will start with the bill that was rejected and see where we can go from there:

What I like about this bill is that it clearly defines the responsibilities of the Chancellor. There's a real benefit there for sure, and after reading it a few more times I may have some thoughts on what else should be included in this list.

I'm not sure whether I like the idea of a directly-elected chancellor, though. The Chancellor has to be someone who the RA can work with, so it seems better to let the RA select from those who choose to self-nominate for the position as under the current process. But clearly there are several points of view on this: Jon, for one, seems to be seriously opposed, and I'd be interested to hear what his specific concerns are. I could guess, of course, but I prefer to let others voice their own opinions rather than try to put words in their mouths.

Cindy

Jon Seattle
I need a hobby
I need a hobby
Posts: 648
Joined: Mon May 29, 2006 6:18 am

Re: Chancellor reform

Post by Jon Seattle »

Cindy wanted me to be more detailed on my response, so here goes. I will just copy and paste from the last debate on this issue:

http://forums.slcds.info/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=1272

When you have a winner-take-all system (as any directly elected executive would be) everyone who did not vote for winner is deprived of a voice. While in an RA all groups are represented.

The RA and the Chancellor, at least right now, have different functions. The RA is not supposed to meddle directly in implementation, and the executive branch is not supposed to make policy.

So if I read you correctly your "give it back to the people" approach ends up depriving a large number of citizens of their voice on the executive side, muddies policy and implementation roles, and moves the focus away from a public consideration of visions and plans for the CDS and towards a popularity contest between individuals.

This does not sound too appetizing to me.

And I can add other things about due process, and the danger of allowing the Chancellor land-swap/taking etc. But the thing is, if this already has the votes to support it there is no point in debating it again.

Dnate Mars
Veteran debater
Veteran debater
Posts: 285
Joined: Fri May 26, 2006 9:32 am

Re: Chancellor reform

Post by Dnate Mars »

Jon Seattle wrote:

Ah the "US President" bill. This was problematic the first time it was introduced. Can I take is that this bill, as written, already has the support of the SP, NuCARE, and DPU? If so, no point on my commenting.

If I didn't want a debate, I wouldn't have brought this up again. This bill got a majority vote, just not the supermajority that was required to change the constitution. Chancellor reform needs to be done, I want the best way to do it.

Dnate Mars
Veteran debater
Veteran debater
Posts: 285
Joined: Fri May 26, 2006 9:32 am

Re: Chancellor reform

Post by Dnate Mars »

for referance, this is the current wording:

Article II - The Executive

Section 1 - The Chancellor

The Chancellor will serve as the executive of CDS, working to coordinate and plan community projects.

Section 2 - Powers of the Chancellor

The Chancellor of Neufreistadt-CDS shall, subject to the laws of CDS, have the power:

(a) to determine the use to which any and all land in Neufriestadt shall be put;

(b) to expend monies held by the Office of the Chancellor of CDS for the administration and management of public facilities (including, but not limited to, roadways, signage, public buildings, public events and similar), and to discharge any other duties or powers of the Office of the Chancellor conferred by this Act or any other Act of the Representative Assembly;

(c) to publicise CDS;

(d) to appoint and pay deputies or other staff to hold office in the Office of the Chancellor of CDS to facilitate the discharge of any function of the Office of the Chancellor conferred by this Act or any other Act of the Representative Assembly;

(e) subject to the payment of adequate compensation to any citizen or citizens thereby affected, reclaim or swap any land held by any citizen of CDS for the purposes of discharging any function of the Office of the Chancellor conferred by this Act or any other Act of the Representative Assembly, provided always that no citizen of CDS shall not be caused to have no holding in Neufriestadt at all thereby;

(f) to make regulations pursuant to the above; and

(g) to enforce such regulations in accordance with law.

Section 3 - Public Oversight

The Chancellor must provide for regular and active citizen participation and public review of any decision concerning land use or the aesthetic or functional environment.

Section 4 - Themes

Nothing in this Act shall give the Chancellor of CDS any power to change the overall theme of Neufriestadt or any other sim or administered component of the CDS.

Section 5 - Chancellor Selection Process

The Chancellor of the CDS shall be selected by the Representative Assembly from among any CDS citizen who shall make application to the RA.

The application period shall begin when the membership of a new RA is named and end the first day of the new RA term. This provision shall come into force with the next RA election following passage and ratification of this amendment. (ed. note: the Seventh RA)

The chancellor will serve a term ending with the election of the next chancellor by the incoming RA.

The Chancellor may not be elected to or serve on the Representative Assembly, nor serve on the Scientific Council. The Chancellor may hold a position in the Artisanal Collective but may not vote therein.

Section 6 - The Chancellor's Veto

The Chancellor shall have the power to veto any act of the Representative Assembly, except any bill to remove the Chancellor from office. The Representative Assembly may override a veto with a vote by at least a two-thirds majority. In order to exercise the power of veto, the Chancellor shall post a public declaration of her or his intention to exercise that power, together with the name of the the Act in respect of which he or she seeks so to exercise, and the reasons for exercising it in respect of that Act, on the Confederation of Democratic Simulators web forums or wiki within seven days of the posting to the wiki of the Act in respect of which he or she seeks to exercise that power.

Section 7 - Removal from Office

The Chancellor may be removed from office prior to the expiration of the term of office by at least a two thirds vote of the Representative Assembly.

Section 8 - RA Oversight

Each month the Chancellor shall attend a meeting of the Representative Assembly, and fully and truthfully answer there any questions posed by any citizen about any aspect of the affairs of the CDS or of the Office of the Chancellor. The Chancellor will also attend upon three days notice at the written request from any member of the Representative Assembly.

Section 9 - AC Overlap

Any power or responsibility assigned to the Artisan's Collective by the constitution and precedent that overlaps those provided to the Chancellor in this amendment will be assigned to the Chancellor.

Beathan
Forum Wizard
Forum Wizard
Posts: 1364
Joined: Sun Oct 29, 2006 3:42 pm

Re: Chancellor reform

Post by Beathan »

Jon Seattle wrote:

Ah the "US President" bill. This was problematic the first time it was introduced. Can I take is that this bill, as written, already has the support of the SP, NuCARE, and DPU? If so, no point on my commenting.

No Jon, you cannot take this proposal this way. I, for one, was not fully onboard with details of the bill before -- and I don't see what has changed. However, as a starting point on a debate people want to have -- this is a good one.

Beathan

Let's keep things simple enough to be fair, substantive enough to be effective, and insightful enough to be good.
Flyingroc Chung
Passionate Protagonist
Passionate Protagonist
Posts: 198
Joined: Thu May 25, 2006 2:55 pm
Contact:

Re: Chancellor reform

Post by Flyingroc Chung »

I don't even know there is consensus on this within the DPU. My own instinct is I don't want another amendment right now :-/. What are we trying to fix tho? Is there really something structurally wrong with the position?

Post Reply

Return to “Legislative Discussion”