General Master Plan 2009

Forum for the CDS Artisan Guild


Moderator: SC Moderators

User avatar
Moon Adamant
I need a hobby
I need a hobby
Posts: 873
Joined: Sun May 28, 2006 1:26 pm

General Master Plan 2009

Post by Moon Adamant »

Hello all,

I will publish next the few sheets that are at the moment the GMP for the CDS. This is a work in progress - not only on my side, as we can understand that more drawings must be made - but also because it will be discussed in this forum and at the Guild, previously to further discussion at RA level.

You may know the excellent GMP made by Symo which is right now in force, and you may have attended the discussion that led to that formulation. This 2009 plan is an expansion of the previous plan, and before we go into details, it's best to understand what is a GMP.

A GMP is always a work-in-progress document, since it relates to something that is continuously changing - territory. This is even more true in Second Life, where new islands can be added by the click of a button, terrain be lifted within minutes, a house be rezzed in one moment. So, a GMP has two primary functions:

a) record faithfully, at a given data, what the territory consists of. The data collected refers both to geographical assets such as orography, transport ways, protected areas, etc, as also to more demographically related data, such as densities of ocupation, existence of social infrastructure and similar issues.
b) preview, with base in the recorded data and by means of other instruments such as polls, direct orders from the managing power, etc, what will be the natural expansion or organization of the territory. (In RL, for example, where territories are generally finite, GMPs can and do record ecological and agrarian zones to be kept, while at the same time organize the expansion of residential zones). In SL, a GMP must thus preview the expansion of the territory, since this is a feature of the SL territory itself - it is expandable at any moment.

The following plan then has two chapters - the first drawings and table refer to the territory as it is now, in March of 2009. The following drawings are the expansion drawings, that include not only the stupendous work done by Symo as also several new features, that weren't an issue at the time Symo drew the plan in force:
i) the desire of many of our citizens to have a taller mountain in our territory
ii) the possibility of joining the Al-Andaluz territory and community to the CDS, which has led also to the conception of Pelagic sims (watery sims with low density that can be used as a watery band that connects all the clusters of the Plan)
iii) the existence of an Act that allows private development of sims, which has led to the appearance of a dedicated project - the Monastery sim.

This plan does also have a new feature that Symo didn't need, which are the definition of Detail Plans. Detail Plans are special areas of a territory that have a plan of its own (while in accordance to the General Plan). The Detail feature allows the territory planner to look closer at the territory in that point, and allows him to create special "rules" for that territory. In RL, Detail Plans are often used either to protect determinate areas (such as an area of particular agrarian or ecological interest), dive into detail into city centres so as to define commercial and other characteristics, or, very importantly, they are used to protect the urban issue around a monument, 'freezing' the time in that area, by inclusively dictating the use of building materials, etc.

The Detail Plans that are defined in this GMP are not so restrictive :) In fact, their intention it's just the opposite. They are defined to contain two particular areas:
- The Al-Andaluz cluster, which has features of its own and has already several sims. In this GMP, the option was made to preview only the location of Alhambra and Generalife, and mandate a third sim to provide a natural coastline in the connection with the rest of the CDS cluster. The location and characteristics of the remaining sims are best confined in teh scope of a Detail Plan.
- The Monastery Sim (location: AM-West), for which there is already a development plan, but which requires for execution some political and economical conditions. When these are realized, the development plan can become the Detail Plan and the sim can be developed.

Many of you will be surprised at the apparent simplicity of the drawings that i will post next. The reason is this: a GMP in the territory conditions of Second Life, and in what it relates to a growing, changing community, as we have seen, must be the less dictatorial as possible, so that a great deal of liberty can be used when finally planning the development of sim X or sim Z. So you will not see detail, but will see only the minimal conditions for expansion and organization of our territory. This should be the tone of the further discussion on this matter: think minimal conditions, not detail.

Last edited by Moon Adamant on Sat Mar 21, 2009 12:01 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Eudaimonia now!
User avatar
Moon Adamant
I need a hobby
I need a hobby
Posts: 873
Joined: Sun May 28, 2006 1:26 pm

Re: Genral Master Plan 2009

Post by Moon Adamant »

This sheet records the geographical data for the current territory (March 2009). Observe please that we still don't have faithful data regarding NFS. It is in reality extremely difficult to record plot and orography data in NFS without a crawler, which we don't have.

Image

Please right-click and use View Image to see it fully.

Eudaimonia now!
User avatar
Moon Adamant
I need a hobby
I need a hobby
Posts: 873
Joined: Sun May 28, 2006 1:26 pm

Re: Genral Master Plan 2009

Post by Moon Adamant »

This table shows the demographic data of our territory at this given moment. You will notice that the NFS values aren't correct, related to what was mentioned in the previous post.

Image

Please right-click and use View Image to see the whole sheet.

Eudaimonia now!
User avatar
Moon Adamant
I need a hobby
I need a hobby
Posts: 873
Joined: Sun May 28, 2006 1:26 pm

Re: Genral Master Plan 2009

Post by Moon Adamant »

This is the first of the Expansion sheets. It defines the clusters (which as you know are thematic-related), provides expansion routes to the territory and attributes to each sim an univocal number that locates it in the GMP and in its cluster.

As you can observe, there are several clusters more than the two that we already have: Alpine and Roman. Similarly to Symo's plan, this plan also previews the existence of a medieval greek cluster (Nea Hora) and a middle-europe cluster (Mittel-Europe). It features as new clusters:
a) the Al-Andaluz cluster
b) the mountain cluster
c) the pelagic band

A note on the mountain cluster - you may be a bit surprised at how big it is, but it's the necessary width and breadth so that with inclinations slightly lower than that of AM we can reach an altitude of above the clouds in the two central sims. Also it is not connected to the Alpine cluster. The reason to this is that we can't, since all the north sims of that cluster preview a corner with water at 20 m, we can't stretch the terrain more in height to reach that kind of altitudes. Not only stretched terrain looks extremely awful (anyone in doubt about this go to NFS' SE corner and observe what is happening at the Chasm), as it also doesn't allow us to create orographical features that are 1) proper of a mountain terrain, such as high valleys, passes, promontories, and 2) difficults in extreme the location of plots and the building of the same.

Image

Please right-click and use View Image to see the whole sheet.

Last edited by Moon Adamant on Sun Mar 22, 2009 5:28 am, edited 1 time in total.
Eudaimonia now!
User avatar
Moon Adamant
I need a hobby
I need a hobby
Posts: 873
Joined: Sun May 28, 2006 1:26 pm

Re: Genral Master Plan 2009

Post by Moon Adamant »

This is the orography drawing of the Plan. A new category of sims was created - Slope - to accomodate the several sims that are mountain sides but need to touch the standard level of water at least at one corner.

You will notice that the pelagic band is blank, which doesn't exclude the creation of islets with a bit of relief to locate plots. Similarly, Nea Hora is assumed as flatish, since most of this cluster will have water connections at the standard height of 20 meters - meaning that some hills are possible but that they won't exceed a certain altitude.

Image

Please right-click and use View Image to see the whole sheet

Eudaimonia now!
User avatar
Moon Adamant
I need a hobby
I need a hobby
Posts: 873
Joined: Sun May 28, 2006 1:26 pm

Re: Genral Master Plan 2009

Post by Moon Adamant »

This drawing illustrates the densities expected for the territory. A premise was made at this point: that in all sims, except in the Detail Plans, the sims are full sims with prim multipliers. This model (AM model) has proved to give great flexibility in the planning of sims, as also of being an economical 'good choice' for our territory. (The economics of sims are published somewhere else in these forums, please refer to Sudane if you'd like to discuss the matter more in detail).

Three points should be of note here:
1) the natural occurrence of low densities at the top of the mountain cluster and at the pelagic band. These sims, if full sims, should be able to provide very good multipliers to their plots, thus adding valour to the said plots.
2) The overall definition of mid-densities throughout the plan, except where we have already city cores, which must be expanded. If using the AM model, the mid-densities allow us to provide for a lot of green space and general beauty of the sims, without losing economic feasibility.
3) information for Al-Andaluz isn't available yet.

Image

Please right-click and use View Image to see the full sheet.

Eudaimonia now!
Jon Seattle
I need a hobby
I need a hobby
Posts: 648
Joined: Mon May 29, 2006 6:18 am

Re: General Master Plan 2009

Post by Jon Seattle »

This is amazing and excellent work!

Salzie Sachertorte
Passionate Protagonist
Passionate Protagonist
Posts: 162
Joined: Fri May 26, 2006 10:00 am

Re: General Master Plan 2009

Post by Salzie Sachertorte »

Excellent work Moon.

Last edited by Salzie Sachertorte on Tue Mar 24, 2009 10:47 am, edited 1 time in total.
Rose Springvale
Forum Wizard
Forum Wizard
Posts: 1074
Joined: Tue Nov 28, 2006 12:29 am

Re: General Master Plan 2009

Post by Rose Springvale »

Just pointing out that there has been no plan to merge with Al Andalus presented nor approved, that no plan of moving the six Al Andalus sims has been considered and that the position of the Al Andalus sims in this draft doesn't even comply with placement that has been discussed informally. I'm not sure why we would consider a move that doesnt' attach the land to land at all, nor do i understand why an additional full sim would be added. Perhaps the reference on these maps should be more generic.

User avatar
Moon Adamant
I need a hobby
I need a hobby
Posts: 873
Joined: Sun May 28, 2006 1:26 pm

Re: General Master Plan 2009

Post by Moon Adamant »

Rose Springvale wrote:

Just pointing out that there has been no plan to merge with Al Andalus presented nor approved, that no plan of moving the six Al Andalus sims has been considered and that the position of the Al Andalus sims in this draft doesn't even comply with placement that has been discussed informally. I'm not sure why we would consider a move that doesnt' attach the land to land at all, nor do i understand why an additional full sim would be added. Perhaps the reference on these maps should be more generic.

Well, the joining with Al-Andaluz is a political topic of the moment, so the GMP can't ignore that. Mind also that the placement hasn't been discussed informally with me :) otherwise, i would have taken your wishes into consideration. Mind though that this is a first sketch (please refer to last meeting's transcript) and that large changes will occur in the overall design.
In any case, a transitional sim will always be needed, be it watery or landmass, between the arab features of Al-Andaluz and whatever to it connects.

Eudaimonia now!
Rose Springvale
Forum Wizard
Forum Wizard
Posts: 1074
Joined: Tue Nov 28, 2006 12:29 am

Re: General Master Plan 2009

Post by Rose Springvale »

This GMP discussion is starting to sound more and more like the discussion pre Alpine meadow when everyone said.. "it can't be done".. it being the joining of NFS and CN. It is SL. The limitations are our imagination. Clearly, AM exists and is lovely. We didn't get to that place by saying.. NFS is too high to connect to CN. We looked at altenatives to make happen what we wanted to happen.

The comment on the "arab features of Al Andalus" are the same. Land has no features. Politics do. If the intent is to keep the politics separating the masses, then sure, we need some sort of artificial barrier. If the intent is to join, then we need creative ways to look at joining. Fortunately for us, the land moving equipment of SL is not expensive nor hard to operate. Andalucia in rl connects effectively to mountains, plains and sea. I'm having a little trouble understanding the issue of whatever it connects to. If it connects to CDS at all! Perhaps CDS will choose to connect to Al Andalus! .. my point is that WE don't know.

I'm also a bit disturbed by all the conversation on the "gaps"... many many sims in SL effectively utilize mountains withought leaving their tree roots showing. For a fine example of a snowy mountain that has done so, please visit the Alpine Executive Center.

I appreciate the work you are doing Moon, and as always, your execution is fabulous. But 52 sims?? Can't we just approach this project with the attitude that we CAN do things, rather than figuring out why they cannot be done?

It is 2009, the year of yes, we can, after all.

User avatar
Moon Adamant
I need a hobby
I need a hobby
Posts: 873
Joined: Sun May 28, 2006 1:26 pm

Re: General Master Plan 2009

Post by Moon Adamant »

Rose, please read the thread carefully and the transcript of last meeting. Nowhere it is said this is a last plan, everywhere it is said this is the basis for discussion. That discussion will happen on this thread and on the WG meetings, every Thursday, at 1 PM SLT, as decided on last Board meeting. You are free, and in fact i do expect that you will participate on both.

Eudaimonia now!
Rose Springvale
Forum Wizard
Forum Wizard
Posts: 1074
Joined: Tue Nov 28, 2006 12:29 am

Re: General Master Plan 2009

Post by Rose Springvale »

Thank you Moon. Thursdays at 1 pm are not good times for people who hold jobs in the US, but i will do my best to participate.However, as the Al Andalus portion is, as you correctly point out, a political question, and as i have an easily recognized conflict of interest i am not willing to waive, i won't be participating in any meeting or conversation from the CDS perspective regarding Al Andalus. Until such time as our politicians determine this to be a true potential, we should not spend our time on the issue. It creates friction where i'm sure none is intended,including the lack of considerations of prior discussions from the prior GMP draft. Above all, i am opposed to wasting the most precious resource we have in CDS, that being the time of our citizens. Right now, i can't see anyone who is happy.. not the mountain people, not the nea hora people, not the monastery people, not the al andalus people. Perhaps the GMP isn't such a good idea when it comes to civic unity after all.

User avatar
Timo Gufler
Veteran debater
Veteran debater
Posts: 281
Joined: Thu Oct 16, 2008 6:17 am
Contact:

Re: General Master Plan 2009

Post by Timo Gufler »

Thanks Moon (and Symo) for your proposal. It's nice to see Nea Hora and Pelagic as a new cluster in the plan and also good there are finally mountains in included. However, I think there is something that could be different...

* The Alpine and Middle-European clusters are still quite small compared to the other clusters and they seem to be very popular. There is an expansion arrow to the east but currently there are other sims on the way in that direction.

* There are other sims in the south preventing mountain expansion in that direction without relocating the whole CDS. Also some people would like to have mountains and place them near NFS. I like that idea too.

I think the best solution to these problems is to join the alpine and mountain clusters that would allow seamless and natural expansion of the alpine theme and to have free space for the mountains.

To try to help with the changes being considered, I have made a simple diagram that might be helpful. As it's said, one picture is worth of thousands words, and maybe that's also a good approach in this case to clarify my thoughts but not a final answer to everything. :wink:

Image

User avatar
Moon Adamant
I need a hobby
I need a hobby
Posts: 873
Joined: Sun May 28, 2006 1:26 pm

Re: General Master Plan 2009

Post by Moon Adamant »

Very good suggestion Timo!

At first view, we can get a mountain almost twice as high as NFS - but i will need to look at that with more attention to make sure. In any case, it's sure that the relief can go above the cloud layer easily.

I like your sugestion of creating a large valley for Mittel-Europe, i am sure it will look splendid. We only have one issue there, which is NFS-East, which should be reserved for expansion of the city of NFS, so it should be alpinish... german :D but we can have a look at that later on, since it's probable that this sim will have a complex covenant similar to NFS, with City zones and outskirt zones - and we can do the transition that way.

An excellent solution that allows us further expansion in all directions when we outgrow this! :)... if you don't mind i will work over your sketch for thursday, since i think it clearly meets the desires of the WG, and we will discuss it further next thursday.

Thanks a lot! :)

Eudaimonia now!
Post Reply

Return to “CDS Artisan Guild”