Reviewing the CDS Code

Proposals for legislation and discussions of these

Moderator: SC Moderators

Post Reply
Publius Crabgrass
Passionate Protagonist
Passionate Protagonist
Posts: 143
Joined: Wed Sep 27, 2006 5:12 pm

Reviewing the CDS Code

Post by Publius Crabgrass »

Yesterday's RA meeting passed a substantially modified version of my "Kill Bill", appointing a commission chaired by yours truly to review all of the bills and establish a "CDS laws in force" page on the wiki. (Thanks, Claude, for already jump starting that process.)

We need to keep our laws accessible to our citizens and others. I'm asking any interested CDS citizens to enlist in this important process.

I'm not sure whether this request should be more properly filed under "General" or "Judiciary" discussions, but I hope it will reach interested parties here.

User avatar
Pelanor Eldrich
Veteran debater
Veteran debater
Posts: 246
Joined: Fri May 26, 2006 10:07 am

Re: CDS Code as Amended

Post by Pelanor Eldrich »

Publius: I'd be interested in reading and helping out. I was a bit startled at the "in force" list on the wiki, but Ali has explained it to me.

I think we need to read all the code and determine:

-What is moribund/obsolete/accomplished (e.g. Relocation of Gwynnethstrasse Act)
-What is superceded/repealed (e.g. Defense of the Republic Act)
-What has been amended (e.g. what's left of the JA)
-What has been implemented by the executive
-What has not been implemented by the executive (e.g. 3-11 bond act)
-What needs amending in terms of conflict within the code (tricky, SC opinion?) and outdated names (e.g. Neualtenburg)

Then we'd have a comprehensive and updated [b:wh96am47]Code as Amended[/b:wh96am47], perhaps passed as an Omnibus Code Housecleaning Act.

Salzie also makes the good point that we don't need a bill every time we want to move a street or do something very minor. The Chancellor can take care of that. At the most it's an announcement or alteration of internal policies and procedures.

Once the code as amended is ready, perhaps the RA can recommend priorities for code implementation and enforcement to the Chancellor.

Determining those priorities is up to the Chancellor, and we must recognize that it's easier to pass legislation than it is to implement it with scripts, code and prims (e.g. Group Owned Land Act was easier to pass than implementing it with the new Land Registration System).

Pelanor Eldrich
Principal - Eldrich Financial
User avatar
Sleazy_Writer
Master Word Wielder
Master Word Wielder
Posts: 429
Joined: Wed Dec 06, 2006 6:38 am

Post by Sleazy_Writer »

[quote="Publius Crabgrass":1me7g1ls]I have a very modest plot on Gwynethstrasse which I have opened as the Constitution Store, where one can buy unlimited copies of the most recent version of the CDS constitution for L$0.[/quote:1me7g1ls]Unlimited, wow :-) I was just thinking the other day how great the 'as amended' version is, yep I like it a lot.

Which brings me to this thread, another important initiative. Is there already decided what the categories for the reorganisation will be?

Also, if you guys look at one act but get stuck somewhere, why not do a quick post on this forum, I'm sure people can give some good feedback about the act's status.

User avatar
Pelanor Eldrich
Veteran debater
Veteran debater
Posts: 246
Joined: Fri May 26, 2006 10:07 am

Publius' first spreadsheet

Post by Pelanor Eldrich »

I got a copy of this a while back. The second post I was not able to access. I haven't looked at this too carefully, but my only quibble so far is that 3-11 has not been superceded by the loan act but rather just hasn't been implemented yet.

Here's the list (thanks to Publius):
[quote:1v1unvqz]Status
In Force NL 3-1 Fountain Act
Historical NL 3-2 City Lag Reduction Act
Historical NL 3-3 Tiny City Removal Act
Historical NL 3-4 Casino Removal Act
Historical NL 3-5 Holiday Chalet Rental Act
Superceded NL 3-6 MoCA Act
Historical NL 3-7 Rathaus Act
Superceded NL 3-8 Texture Size Reduction Act
In Force NL 3-9 US Dollar Accounting Act
Superceded NL 3-10 Construction Authority Act (superceded by NL 4-20)
Superceded NL 3-11 Neualtenburg Bond Act
In Force NL 3-12 Neualtenburg Notary Act
Historical NL 4-1 Guildhall Act
In Force NL 4-2 Marketplatz Zoning Act
In Force NL 4-3 Land Sales Reporting Act
Superceded NL 4-4 Election Scheduling Act (repealed)
In Force NL 4-5 Central Commercial District Land Fee Act
In Force NL 4-6 Financial Reserves Act
Historical NL 4-7 Central Commercial District Land Allocation Act
In Force NL 4-8 Scientific Council Affirmation Procedures Act
Historical NL 4-9 Expansion Planning Act
In Force NL 4-10 Prim Farm Act
Superceded NL 4-11 Citizenship Expansion Act (The Microplot Act) (repealed by NL 5-10)
In Force NL 4-12 MoCA Charter Acceptance Act
In Force NL 4-13 MoCA Franchise Agreement
In Force NL 4-14 Registration and Incorporation Act
In Force NL 4-15 Neualtenburger Bank Act
In Force NL 4-16 Public Prim Allotment Act
Historical NL 4-17 Anzere Infohub Act
In Force NL 4-18 City Building Redundancy Act
In Force NL 4-19 Neualtenburg School Charter Acceptance Act
In Force NL 4-20 Construction Authority Act (supercedes NL 3-10)
In Force NL 4-21 Public Building Deletion Act
Historical NL 4-22 Housing Restitution Act
In Force NL 4-23 Public Property Protection Act
Superceded NL 4-24 Defense of the Republic Act
In Force NL 4-25 RA Vacancy Act
Superceded NL 4-26 Public Information Act
Historical NL 4-27 Naming Procedures Act
Historical NL 4-28 Rebuilding Funding Act
In Force NL 5-1 Flag Act
In Force NL 5-2 Fundraising for Expansion Act
Historical NL 5-3 Gwynethstrasse Relocation Act
In Force NL 5-4 Franchulate Act
In Force NL 5-5 Treasurer Act
In Force NL 5-6 Estate Owner Act
In Force NL 5-7 Civil Service Act
In Force NL 5-8 Covenant Revision Act
In Force NL 5-9 Group Land Ownership Act
In Force NL 5-10 Microplot Termination Act
In Force NL 5-11 Judiciary Act (partially repealed)
In Force NL 5-12 Land Deed Format Amendment Act
Historical NL 5-13 Judiciary and Scientific Council Finance Act
In Force NL 5-14 Colonia Nova Project Debt Limit Act
In Force NL 5-15 Citizen Information Act
In Force NL 5-16 An Act Establishing a Special Commission on the Judiciary and Revising the Judicial Code of Procedure (aka The Soothsayer Rules)
In Force NL 5-17 Census Scheduling Act
In Force NL 5-18 Faction Membership Reporting Act
In Force NL 5-19 Judiciary Revision Procedure Act
In Force NL 5-20 Arbitration Act
In Force NL 5-21 Citizen Involvement Act
In Force NL 5-22 Regional Planning Commission Act
Historical NL 6-1 Code Reorganization Commission Act
[/quote:1v1unvqz]
-Pel

Pelanor Eldrich
Principal - Eldrich Financial
User avatar
Sleazy_Writer
Master Word Wielder
Master Word Wielder
Posts: 429
Joined: Wed Dec 06, 2006 6:38 am

Post by Sleazy_Writer »

Great :-) Let's discuss this some time .. will be interesting. After taking a quick look, a few things:

- Why not mention by *which* act another act is superceded? You guys are figuring this out anyway and it'll increase clarity.
- No differentiation between accomplished historical acts and those still in progress? (like this Reorganisation Commission)
- NL 5-22 is historical, by now. The Regional Planning Commission has delivered its report and their work is finished.
- Can someone please explain the status of NL 5-13? Why is it not repealed or superceded? I thought we didn't have a chief judge anymore? Or are these payments now made to the SC Dean? 5-13's status is not clear to me.

Let me say it again, this is a great initiative :-)

- - - -
[i:o2n0qsg5]Btw, what about representing the statuses like this:[/i:o2n0qsg5]

[img:o2n0qsg5]http://schallplatten.files.wordpress.co ... toicon.png[/img:o2n0qsg5] NL 7-1 Lame Jokes Investigation Commission Act
[img:o2n0qsg5]http://schallplatten.files.wordpress.co ... ceicon.png[/img:o2n0qsg5] NL 7-2 Mineral Water Health Act (superceded by NL 7-3)
[img:o2n0qsg5]http://schallplatten.files.wordpress.co ... nicon2.png[/img:o2n0qsg5] NL 7-3 N'stadt Brau Revitalization Act
[img:o2n0qsg5]http://schallplatten.files.wordpress.co ... nicon2.png[/img:o2n0qsg5] NL 7-4 Unlimited Power to the Chancellor Act
[img:o2n0qsg5]http://schallplatten.files.wordpress.co ... toicon.png[/img:o2n0qsg5] NL 7-5 Fifth Sim Budget Act

Of course we would have a small legend at the bottom, but this is pretty clear, no? And we wouldn't need to have 2 or 3 different lists of laws.

Post Reply

Return to “Legislative Discussion”